How to Make Decisions with a Catholic Mindset—Without Regret
The Dilemma: A Story of Faith in Action
Maria sat in her car, hands gripping the steering wheel, staring at the email on her phone. It was a job offer—higher pay, better title, more prestige. But something inside her hesitated. The role required long hours, travel every weekend, and turning a blind eye to certain company policies that made her uneasy. She had prayed for career growth, but was this the right opportunity?
She sighed, remembering her father’s words: "When you make decisions, Maria, don’t just think about what you gain—think about what you become."
That night, she prayed. She read Scripture. She sought counsel from her parish priest. And finally, she made her decision—not just with her mind, but with her soul. She turned down the offer. It didn’t align with her faith, her values, or the life she wanted to live.
Weeks later, another opportunity came—one that paid less but gave her peace, flexibility, and the time to invest in her spiritual life through daily mass, adoration, reading of the scripture and serve her community more.
In hindsight, she knew she had chosen not just a job, but a path that kept her rooted in Christ.
What Does It Mean to Have a Catholic Mindset?
Life is full of decisions—some small, like what to say in a difficult conversation, and some life-changing, like whom to marry or which career path to take. A Catholic mindset means approaching every decision with faith, wisdom, and a heart oriented toward God’s will.
It’s about seeing decisions not just as isolated choices but as opportunities to grow in sanctity, trust in God, and ultimately draw closer to Him. Here’s how you can do that in a practical, relatable way:
1. Start with Prayer—Even When You Don't Have Time
When you’re pressed for time and unsure what to do, that’s precisely when you need to pause and turn to God. Instead of rushing ahead, offer it back to Him: ‘Jesus, I trust in You.’
Prayer isn’t about forcing an answer—it’s about surrendering, allowing God to shape our hearts and guide our steps.
The more we seek Him, the clearer His voice becomes.
2. Look Beyond the Immediate Gain
The world tells us to chase success, comfort, and approval. But Jesus calls us to seek the Kingdom first (Matthew 6:33). Before making a decision, ask yourself:
Will this bring me closer to God or pull me away?
Am I choosing this out of fear, pride, or selfish ambition?
How does this impact my relationships and my ability to love and serve?
A Catholic mindset isn’t about choosing what’s easiest or most rewarding in the short term—it’s about choosing what will form us into the person God calls us to be.
3. Seek Counsel—but Choose Wisely
Not all advice is godly advice. When facing a decision, talk to people who will challenge you spiritually, not just tell you what you want to hear. A good friend, a spiritual mentor, or even reading the lives of saints can provide clarity.
St. Ignatius of Loyola, known for his deep discernment process, encouraged people to weigh decisions by considering their eternal impact. If you imagine yourself at the end of your life, looking back, would you be at peace with this choice?
4. Make the Choice That Brings You Peace
Ever made a decision that looked great on paper but left you restless? That’s often a sign it’s not the right one. God’s will doesn’t always lead to comfort, but it does bring deep peace—the kind that lingers even in difficult situations.
Think of St. Teresa of Calcutta, who left everything behind to serve the poorest of the poor. Her life was far from easy, but she had an unshakable sense of peace because she knew she was where God wanted her to be.
5. Be Ready to Sacrifice
Sometimes, following God’s will means saying no to an opportunity that looks amazing but doesn’t align with your faith. It’s not easy. But choosing God over temporary success always leads to something greater—even if we don’t see it right away.
Maria’s story isn’t unique. Many saints and everyday Catholics have faced similar dilemmas. Choosing faith over worldly gain isn’t about deprivation—it’s about freedom. The freedom to live in truth, to trust in God’s plan, and to know that His ways are always higher than ours (Isaiah 55:8-9).
A Challenge for You
Think about a decision you’re facing right now. Big or small. Instead of rushing into it, take a step back.
Pray about it.
Ask yourself if it aligns with your values.
Seek wisdom from Scripture and people who live out their faith.
Pay attention to your inner peace.
Then, act—not just with logic, but with trust in God’s plan. Because a Catholic mindset isn’t just about making the right choice—it’s about making the choice that forms you into the person God is calling you to be.
Just like Maria, your greatest decisions won’t be about what you gain—but about who you become.
If this message resonates with you, I’d love for us to keep walking this journey together.
Sign up for our weekly newsletter, where we go deeper into finding direction and living out your faith authentically.
When you confirm your subscription, you’ll also receive a free copy of Structured Goals, a free guide to help you turn your aspirations into actionable steps.